2025 Arkansas Derby Preview and Predictions: Coal Battle Set to Strike Again

By WIZCAPPER
Updated: March 24, 2025

Canva

Let’s analyze the 2025 Arkansas Derby at Oaklawn Park using the Brisnet past performance (PP) data for the nine horses entered. The race is a 1 1/8-mile Grade 1 event on dirt with a $1.5 million purse, set for March 29, 2025. I’ll evaluate each horse’s form, pace/speed figures, class experience, trainer/jockey stats, and suitability for the distance and surface, then predict the outcome.

Race Overview

Distance: 1 1/8 miles (9 furlongs)
Surface: Fast Dirt (assumed based on Oaklawn’s typical conditions and PP data)
Pace/Speed Pars: Not explicitly provided, but based on recent Oaklawn 9f races (e.g., Rebel-G2), I’ll estimate E1 ~90-95, E2 ~100-105, Late ~90-95, Speed ~100-105. I’ll adjust as we analyze the field.
Post Time: Not specified; typically late afternoon at Oaklawn (e.g., 6:00 PM CDT).

Horse-by-Horse Analysis

1. Brereton’s Baytown (PP1, P 3)

Prime Power: 126.8 (7th)
Record: 10 starts, 2-0-0, $85,773, Avg Speed 88
Strengths:
Sharp 5f workout (Mar-21, 1:00.6).
Won a $40k claimer at 1 1/16m (88) in muddy conditions.
Weaknesses:
Low speed figures (max 88 vs. estimated par 100+).
8th in Rebel-G2 (84) last out; passed tiring rivals only.
Trainer Paul McEntee (0% meet) and jockey Marshall Mendez (0% meet) are unproven here.
No Oaklawn wins (0-0-0 in 1 start).
Fit: Outclassed; lacks the speed and form to compete.

2. First Division (PP2, S 0)

Prime Power: 125.7 (8th)
Record: 3 starts, 1-1-1, $79,800, Avg Speed 85
Strengths:
Trainer Ken McPeek (18% meet) excels with routes (15%).
2nd in last race (OC200k, 1 1/16m, 85) at Oaklawn; strong late pace (103).
Perfect at Oaklawn (1-1-1 in 3 starts).
Sharp 5f workout (Mar-22, :59.4).
Weaknesses:
Low speed figures (max 85 vs. par 100+).
Beaten by weaker in last race as favorite.
Jockey Brian Hernandez Jr. (7% meet) is lukewarm.
Fit: Late runner with Oaklawn affinity, but speed is insufficient.

3. Publisher (PP3, P 2)

Prime Power: 135.9 (5th)
Record: 6 starts, 0-1-3, $137,756, Avg Speed 93
Strengths:
Jockey Flavien Prat (25% meet, 25% routes) is elite.
4th in Rebel-G2 (93) last out; best speed figure in field matches estimated par.
Blinkers on (16% for Asmussen) could sharpen focus.
Sharp 5f workout (Mar-16, 1:01).
Oaklawn form (0-1-0 in 3 starts).
Weaknesses:
Still a maiden after 6 starts; unproven winner.
Trainer Steve Asmussen (10% meet) is below his usual standard.
Fit: Consistent placer with upside; could hit the board.

4. Bestfriend Rocket (PP4, E/P 8)

Prime Power: 125.0 (9th)
Record: 6 starts, 3-0-1, $142,450, Avg Speed 85
Strengths:
Won last race (OC200k, 1 1/16m, 85) at Oaklawn; handles distance.
High early speed (E/P 8); could set the pace.
Trainer D. Wayne Lukas (19% meet, 17% after wins) and jockey Nik Juarez (28% with Lukas L60) are solid.
Sharp 5f workout (Mar-18, 1:00.4).
Weaknesses:
Low speed figures (max 85 vs. par 100+).
Steps up in class after modest foes.
Fit: Pace factor, but speed and class jump are concerns.

5. Speed King (PP5, E 5)

Prime Power: 139.1 (2nd)
Record: 4 starts, 2-1-0, $700,250, Avg Speed 92
Strengths:
Won Southwest-G3 (1 1/16m, 92) at Oaklawn; graded stakes cred.
Jockey Rafael Bejarano (22% meet) and trainer Ron Moquett (17% meet, 34% with Bejarano L60) are hot.
High E2 (106 in Southwest) shows stamina.
Sharp 4f workout (Mar-20, :47.6).
Weaknesses:
10th in Rebel-G2 (80) last out; faded badly.
Speed figures below par (max 92).
Fit: Proven at Oaklawn, but recent flop raises doubts.

6. Sandman (PP6, S 0)

Prime Power: 142.5 (1st)
Record: 7 starts, 2-1-2, $444,595, Avg Speed 95
Strengths:
Highest Prime Power (142.5); 3rd in Rebel-G2 (95) last out.
Jockey Jose Ortiz (50% meet, 23% stalkers) and trainer Mark Casse (19% meet) are top-tier.
Strong late pace (95 in Rebel, 94 in Southwest); suits 9f.
Oaklawn success (1-1-1 in 3 starts).
Weaknesses:
Failed as favorite in Rebel; yet to win in 2025.
Speed figures (max 95) slightly below par.
Fit: Major contender; consistency and closing kick stand out.

7. Monet’s Magic (PP7, S 1)

Prime Power: 128.8 (6th)
Record: 7 starts, 2-0-1, $206,139, Avg Speed 90
Strengths:
Won OC125k (1m, 84) at Oaklawn in December.
Weaknesses:
5th in Southwest-G3 (86) last out; 2-month layoff.
Low speed figures (max 90 vs. par 100+).
Trainer Ben Colebrook (6% meet, 3% graded stakes) and jockey Luan Machado (0% meet) are weak.
Fit: Off-form and outclassed; layoff hurts.

8. Coal Battle (PP8, P 3)

Prime Power: 137.7 (4th)
Record: 7 starts, 5-0-0, $1,053,875, Avg Speed 98
Strengths:
Won Rebel-G2 (1 1/16m, 98) last out; highest speed in field.
Perfect at Oaklawn (2-0-0, avg 98); won Smarty Jones (82).
Jockey Juan Vargas (100% meet, small sample) and trainer Lonnie Briley (16% 2024-25, 100% graded stakes) are clicking.
Five wins show killer instinct.
Weaknesses:
No workouts since Feb 17; fitness a slight concern.
Fit: Top threat; proven winner at this level.

9. Cornucopian (PP9, E 6)

Prime Power: 138.5 (3rd)
Record: 1 start, 1-0-0, $66,000, Avg Speed 100
Strengths:
Highest last-race speed (100, mdn, 6f); matches estimated par.
Trainer Bob Baffert (33% meet, 35% mdn win L/R) and jockey John Velazquez (strong routes) are elite.
Sharp 5f workout (Mar-22, 1:00).
Dominant debut at Oaklawn; heavily bet.
Weaknesses:
Only 1 start; no route experience.
Massive class jump from mdn to G1.
Fit: Huge potential but untested; a wild card.

Race Dynamics and Pace Scenario

Pace Setters: Bestfriend Rocket (E/P 8), Speed King (E 5), and Cornucopian (E 6) could lead. Bestfriend’s recent 9f win suggests he’ll push early.
Pressers: Coal Battle (P 3), Publisher (P 2), and Brereton’s Baytown (P 3) will stalk.
Closers: Sandman (S 0), First Division (S 0), and Monet’s Magic (S 1) will come late.
Projection: Moderate early pace (E1 ~90-95) with Bestfriend Rocket setting it. E2 (~100-105) and Late (~90-95) favor horses with stamina and a kick, aligning with Oaklawn’s speed-holding bias.

Predicted Outcome

Coal Battle (PP8):

Why: Rebel-G2 win (98) at Oaklawn, highest speed in field, and 5-for-7 lifetime. His pressing style (P 3) and Oaklawn dominance (2-0-0) make him the horse to beat. Briley’s 100% graded stakes stat (small sample) adds confidence.
Risk: Lack of recent works, but form is too strong to ignore.

Sandman (PP6):

Why: Highest Prime Power (142.5), 3rd in Rebel (95), and strong late pace (95). Ortiz and Casse are a potent combo, and Oaklawn form (1-1-1) is a plus. Late run suits 9f.
Risk: Yet to win in 2025; needs pace to close into.

Cornucopian (PP9):

Why: Debut 100 speed is field-best, and Baffert’s 35% mdn-to-route stat is elite. Velazquez’s experience helps. Oaklawn win and sharp work (Mar-22) signal readiness.
Risk: One race, no route experience; class jump is steep.

Speed King (PP5):

Why: Southwest-G3 win (92) and Oaklawn success (1-0-0). Hot trainer/jockey combo (34% L60) and early speed (E 5) keep him in mix.
Risk: Rebel flop (10th, 80) questions current form.

Betting Recommendations

Win: Coal Battle (PP8) – Proven G2 winner with Oaklawn mastery.
Exacta: Coal Battle over Sandman (8-6).
Trifecta: Coal Battle, Sandman, Cornucopian (8-6-9).
Superfecta: Add Speed King (8-6-9-5).

Final Thoughts

Coal Battle’s Rebel win and Oaklawn prowess make him the standout, while Sandman’s consistency and Cornucopian’s raw talent offer upside. Speed King could rebound for a piece, and Publisher might sneak into the superfecta. Bestfriend Rocket sets the pace but lacks speed to hold on. The rest (Brereton’s Baytown, First Division, Monet’s Magic) are overmatched.

← Previous Story 2025 Arkansas Derby: Thoughts on Speed King and Cornucopian

Next Story → 2025 Arkansas Derby: How the Rebel Stakes Key Race Shifts the Odds